Issue35

Issue Title Protocol Indicators/Identifiers
Document: GIMPS Protocol Specification v05 Section: 5.5.1, C.4.3, C.4.4
Category: Editorial Priority: Must Fix
Status: Closed

Created on 2005-03-09.20:46:06 by reh, last changed 2005-04-20.13:56:10.

Messages
msg109 Author: reh Date: 2005-04-20.13:55:07
The term "MA-Protocol-ID" is used consistently in version -06 (and there is a
note to say that it is not the same as an IP protocol number).
msg91 Author: reh Date: 2005-03-09.20:46:06
The text in 5.5.1 could be clearer on the fact that the Protocol-Identifier is
*not* the IP protocol number, but a number from a GIMPS registry. (It can't be
the IP protocol number, because some of the protocols are not directly above IP
- like TLS. And even if it was, we could still need different numbers for e.g.
forwards vs. reverse TCP.)

Also, the term Protocol Identifier is not consistent; Protocol Indicator is also
used. (Maybe we should use an obviously GIMPS name, like MA-Protocol-ID.)
History
Date User Action Args
2005-04-20 13:56:10rehsetstatus: Accepted -> Closed
2005-04-20 13:55:38rehsetstatus: Text Proposed -> Accepted
2005-04-20 13:55:07rehsetstatus: No Discussion -> Text Proposed
messages: + msg109
2005-03-09 20:46:06rehcreate